I was prepping for the 2.5-hour drive from Pensacola to the St. Andrews Jetty in Panama City Beach. While a 2.5-hour drive is no big deal, I like to make a trip out of everything I do, so I booked a hotel right outside St. Andrews State Park.
I’ve booked hundreds of hotels over the years, and I have developed a very specific system for finding the best spots.
While my primary purchasing engine is Booking.com, I always start with a macro view using Google Hotels. The large map interface pulls in pricing from various booking agencies that are all tied into the hotel pricing algorithm. Sometimes, a new booking agency will pop up and offer incredible deals for prime locations. You often see this when hotel owners change hands, too. Sometimes the front desk is shocked at the low price I pay when I arrive. I’m guessing the booking agency is taking a loss on the cost of client acquisition, but either way, I take the deal.
Once I find the anomaly on Google, I head to Booking.com to look at the ratings. Over the years, I’ve come to know exactly what to expect based purely on their rating system—with a few calculated caveats.
The 8.0 Rule (And the 7.6 Loophole)
I, like most people, want a clean hotel. I understand that staff members have bad days and struggle, so I basically reject most negative reviews that aren't specifically about cleanliness or Wi-Fi quality. OR if you see the words remodeled
Here is exactly how I break down the ratings:
- 10.0: Generally out of the budget.
- 9.0 – 9.9: Fantastic, but usually pricey. Sometimes you can catch a 9.5 for $120.
- 8.0 – 8.9: The Sweet Spot. If a hotel has an 8.0, it will be a nice, reliable place to stay.
I aim for that 8.0 to 9.0 range, strictly between $100 and $120 a night. Plus, Booking.com often offers a discount on certain hotels that perfectly covers the taxes.
The 7.6 Loophole: I will stoop down to a 7.6 rating only if the negative reviews are just people complaining about the front desk staff or some weird personal service issue. If the ratings show consistent high marks for cleanliness, I’ll jump on a 7.6—especially if it is in a prime location. OR I see remodeled in the past year. Those hotels usually have changed ownership and the cleanliness rating isn't factoring in the new rooms.
The Family Factor
If I were traveling solo, I would sleep on a couch if it was free.
But this rating system is specifically designed for when I am on the road with my family. I want Rebeca, my daughter, and my son to feel safe and be comfortable. If I drag them into sketchy, uncomfortable situations, they are going to start disliking the journey. The goal is to travel full-time, which means keeping the crew happy is priority number one.
For this St. Andrews trip, I actually used the 7.6 loophole. The negative reviews were service complaints and old ratings for comfort, but the hotel is in clear view of the beach and a half-mile from the state park gate. It is a prime location for exactly what I’m doing, and the price was 1/3 the cost of any other hotel in the area. And I saw that it was recently remodeled with newer ratings being in the 8 and 9 range, offsetting the older complaints. I got the hotel for 133 out the door with other hotels in the area being $300 to $500.
The real test will come on arrival, but I usually chalk those deals up to the algorithm trying to fill rooms.
The Under-$70 Danger Zone
The hotel algorithm takes all the properties in the area and prices the rooms based on current and estimated demand. Prices are constantly shifting. The algo tries to fill hotels rooms when they are available, so the rating system dictates how far the price will drop to meet the demand.
You almost never see prime real estate drop below $100, but once and a while you will find a hidden gem at for $85 sitting at a 9,5 or higher.
Once you get below the $70 mark, you are in a different world. You will almost always smell weed and see some pretty wild situations. A lot of those cheap hotels cater to the homeless crowd, which is a surprisingly big market for them. They also tend to attract drug dealers.
One time, I stayed at a hotel in Alexandria, Louisiana. I had never seen so many cars coming in and out of a parking lot. It turns out there were several drug dealers operating out of the hotel that night, and the place was absolutely swarming. It was no surprise that the cops were all over the place the next morning.
The Cash-Only Nightmare
Another time, I stayed at a wild place in California. The reviews were mixed—some said the rooms were clean and new, others said they were old and gross.
I was forced into this booking because my original hotel canceled my reservation to capitalize on a massive surge in local prices. I had no where to stay. Sometimes hotels will do that when the algorithm triples prices due to high demand. It’s sad, but it happens.
I was left with the absolute last available room in the city.
- It had blood stains on the wall.
- There was a gross, musty smell in the room.
- There were cigarette burns on the bed sheets.
- It was absolutely disgusting.
And to top it off, they would only take cash. Consider that a major warning: never stay in a place that won't take your card.
And one more thing. I almost never over pay for hotels due to some event demand. I just avoid it. I'll change dates, change locations or even cancel. Those kind of splurges are the kind of things that cause you to take unnecessary financial losses.
The Bottom Line
You will always run into some strange experiences on the road, but if you stick to a system, you can generally guarantee a specific, safe experience every time you book. It only takes me a few minutes to filter the noise, find the sweet spot in the algorithm, and lock in the perfect basecamp for the next dive.
0 comments